Education Off The Rails: Standards Train Wreck

In Teaching in a Knowledge Society Andy Hargreaves has a cautionary tale – Education off the Rails –  about the effects of applied performance standards that push people all too easily into quick fixes rather than sustainable improvement.

His analogy concerns a stay he had in the UK and a railway meltdown.

In that case, emphasis on standards  turned into standardization and targets met.  Privatisation cut the cost of engineering repairs by contracting them out to private tender. Performance standards replaced long-term accountability. And the consequences were disastrous.

If you really want to improve remember: Culture Eats Standards For Breakfast

His point is that excessive concentration on minimum standards and short-term performance targets can be self-defeating. They can push trains, and education, off the rails by eradicating an established culture.

Cocoa Was Spilt

In the illustration Henry the Green Engine* is derailed because a fall of snow forced the signals down. In that rail disaster,  Cocoa was spilt but no lives lost and Henry was dispatched to Crewe for a new firebox.

Henry the Green Engine by the Rev. W. Awdry.

JosieHolford

View Comments

  • And...you don't need a pencil to take a walk in the jungle.

    Did you have any particular jungle in mind? How will you get there?

  • An educrat once lectured us on how to write lesson plans. "It's like a train," she explained. "You have to have an engine. Those are your objectives."

    After awhile, I decided trains were the exact metaphor I was looking for in terms of standardized education. Trains rip through geography without respect for the ecology, the humanity or the culture. Trains stay on track and never meander. Trains are made to serve economic purposes. They are slow, expensive, and heavily subsidized.

    I would rather my class look like a walk through a jungle than a train ride.
    .-= John Spencer´s last blog ..the effects of a rainy day =-.

Recent Posts

Locked Out

Most of us have done it at some point or another - accidentally locked ourselves…

3 days ago

The #1970 Club: Germaine Greer and The Female Eunuch

Thanks to the #1970 Club, I've spent the spare moments of the past week immersed…

2 weeks ago

The Forgetful Mog

Thanks to the #1970 Club,  I have a new mog in my life and a…

3 weeks ago

The #1970 Club: Language and Learning

The #1970 Club is starting tomorrow (October 14th) and I'm prepared with some reading and…

3 weeks ago

How do they live with themselves?

How Do They Live with Themselves? This was the question Roger Rosenblatt asked in The…

4 weeks ago

On the Road

"The pleasure [of motoring] is seeing Nature as I could in no other way see…

1 month ago