Every year at the annual Eagle Society poetry reading a lower school student demonstrates that s/he has spent homework time memorizing Shel Silversteins’s twelve line epic that begins:

Homework, oh homework I hate you, you stink.

I wish I could wash you away in the sink.

If only a bomb would explode you to bits,

Homework oh homework you’re giving me fits.

ASCD has a new book Rethinking Homework by Cathy Vatterot

There’s a really great review of it here.

Alfie Kohn has an article with the same title: Rethinking Homework.

The usual justifications for assigning homework  include the following assumptions:

  1. The role of the school is to extend learning beyond the classroom.
  2. Intellectual activity is intrinsically more valuable than nonintellectual activity.
  3. Homework teaches responsibility.
  4. Lots of homework is a sign of a rigorous curriculum.
  5. Good teachers give homework; good students do their homework.

But…are they true? Are they universally shared? Do they make sense?

Vatterot’s book takes a good look at these assumptions and suggests that a much needed  overhaul of the homework rationale. As the tools for learning change,  the lines between formal and informal learning blur, as family life shifts, and even small children feel the pressure of pace and lack of time it’s time to step back from the homework panic. There isa correlation between homework and achievement but more hours of drudgery does not equal academic rigor. Global competitiveness is not served by giving small children fits.

More poetry though…? Worth a try.

JosieHolford

Recent Posts

The Soul of Nature: Caspar David Friedrich and Byron’s Childe Harold

A cold, wet February day - perfect backdrop for a journey into Romanticism—off on the…

2 days ago

DEI and Getting Back on Track

Dialogue with Dignity I’ve been thinking about issues of racial justice since I was a…

2 weeks ago

In Love with London Fog

I kept coming across paintings of London by Yoshio Markino - gauzy portraits of a…

2 weeks ago

The Horizontal Man

There’s something irresistible about a crime story set in a school or college. Like the…

4 weeks ago

A Better Class of Train

The two-forty-five express — Paddington to Market Blandings, first stop Oxford—stood at its piatform with…

1 month ago

The Reverse Ferret and the Vicar of Bray

Changing your mind is perfectly normal—and often essential. After all, it’s what education is all…

2 months ago